Displaying first 50 comments.
| 1. Posted By: Jeff - - April 19, 2007, 3:58 pm |
Program/Method: Windows Mapped Drive (X:)
Size of file: 347 MB
Network Type: 802.11b (11 mbps)
Transfer Time: 18 min
Transfer Speed: 2.57 mbps
|
| 2. Posted By: Jeff - - April 22, 2007, 12:50 pm |
Program/Method: Windows File Sharing
Network Type: 802.11g (54 mbps)
Size of file: 685 MB
Transfer Time: 7 min
Transfer Speed: 13.05 mbps
|
| 3. Posted By: Jeff - - April 22, 2007, 12:51 pm |
Program/Method: Mapped Drive (X:)
Network Type: 802.11g (54 mbps)
Size of file: 347 MB
Transfer Time: 3 min
Transfer Speed: 15.42 mbps
|
| 4. Posted By: JG - - May 21, 2007, 10:16 am |
Program/Method: XP Mapped drive
Network Type: 100Mbps NIC on a 1Gbps switch
Size of file: 2490 MB
Transfer Time: 4.5 min
Transfer Speed: 73.78 mbps
|
| 5. Posted By: Chuck - - May 21, 2007, 1:43 pm |
Program/Method: Net Use cross-domain
Network Type: T1
Size of file: 4138 MB
Transfer Time: 22 min
Transfer Speed: 25.08 mbps
|
| 6. Posted By: Mike - - May 22, 2007, 5:58 am |
Program/Method: Mac to windows via Samba share
Network Type: 802.11g wifi
Size of file: 347 MB
Transfer Time: 7 min
Transfer Speed: 6.61 mbps
|
| 7. Posted By: Jeff - - July 27, 2007, 11:35 pm |
Program/Method: Windows File Sharing
Network Type: 802.11g 54mbps
Size of file: 233 MB
Transfer Time: 2 min
Transfer Speed: 15.53 mbps
|
| 8. Posted By: compguyeye - - July 28, 2007, 12:01 am |
Program/Method: Mapped Drive
Network Type: 1000base or I gig/ 6E
Size of file: 666 MB
Transfer Time: 3 min
Transfer Speed: 29.6 mbps
Transfer from a VM server to workstation (Vista).
|
| 9. Posted By: Jeff - - July 28, 2007, 12:24 am |
Program/Method: windows shared drive letter X:
Network Type: 100mbps ethernet
Size of file: 6300 MB
Transfer Time: 15 min
Transfer Speed: 56 mbps
|
| 10. Posted By: internet-jeff - - September 12, 2007, 3:10 pm |
Program/Method: filezilla ftp client to Mac OS X FTPD
Network Type: IEEE 1394
Size of file: 1073 MB
Transfer Time: 7 min
Transfer Speed: 20.44 mbps
|
| 11. Posted By: Brad - - September 19, 2007, 10:03 am |
Program/Method: FTP, VSFTPd Server, FileZilla client
Network Type: 100mbps ethernet
Size of file: 571 MB
Transfer Time: 57 seconds
Transfer Speed: 76 Mbit
|
| 12. Posted By: Brad - - September 19, 2007, 10:03 am |
Program/Method: Mapped drive, Win2003 Server, Win 2000 client
Network Type: 100mbps ethernet
Size of file: 390 MB
Transfer Time: 44 seconds
Transfer Speed: 67 Mbit
|
| 13. Posted By: Brad - - September 19, 2007, 10:07 am |
Program/Method: iSCSI, iscsid Linux Server, Windows XP w/MS iscsi initiator client
Network Type: 1000mbps ethernet
Size of file: 1073739776B (~1GB)
Transfer Time: 20.8 seconds
Transfer Speed: 393 Mbit (!)
WiFi is for web browsing, not file serving. Which I think you've already discovered. Waiting 20+ minutes for a file to copy is painful!
Good luck,
Brad
|
| 14. Posted By: Lee - - December 4, 2007, 7:44 am |
Program/Method: Robocopy
Network Type: 100mbps ethernet
Size of file: 170000 MB
Transfer Time: 7200 min
Transfer Speed: 3.15 mbps
This is a rubbish transfer speed for Robocopy. Five days to copy 170GB isn't good at all. But then I discovered that the 64-bit version of Server 2003 has some issues (which is the server I'm copying to) so perhaps that has some bearing on things.
My previous copy was from 32-bit server 2003 to XP and that took less than two days.
|
| 15. Posted By: Martin Padilla B - padillabravo@hotmail.com - January 17, 2008, 6:14 pm |
Program/Method: windows mapped drive
Network Type: 100 mbps ethernet
Size of file: 10000 MB
Transfer Time: 18 min
Transfer Speed: 74.07 mbps
Also, I used unstopable copier to make a backup of an old hardisk to a new. The whole directory was aprox 10 Gb.
|
| 16. Posted By: helios - - February 18, 2008, 9:35 am |
I think you needed to do more testing.
I've done some personal testing on a 100mbps network and found similar results that when you use a mapped network drive that you can not even come close to getting the full available bandwidth.
However, I routinely use Filezilla to do transfers and can completely saturate the link - i.e. 100mbps, even with one transfer, not to mention filezilla's ability to do multithreaded transfers.
Another note, Filezilla's compression can work wonders on compressible files - for instance, a 300MB test file will compress well and transfer unbelieveably fast - however, a zip file with 300MB of MP3 or JPG files will transfer at wire speed.
|
| 17. Posted By: Mathew7 - - March 20, 2008, 12:57 am |
I made a small test using 100Mbps network between 2 computers that were connected through 5 switches (a cascading neighborhood network). The results:
FTP: 9MB/s
Windows file sharing: 7MB/s
When using only 1 switch, it is a tie.
For FTP I used Vermillion FTP Daemon, which was a lightweight FTP server.
So in case you use a low-latency (not speed) network, you are better with FTP.
The reason: FTP sends burts with the file contents, so it could have sent 10 packets before receiving any acknowledge of transmission. Windows file sharing uses a request-grant scheme: the client request a small part of the file and the server sends it. But the next request is made only after receiving the previous part. MS may have some handling improvements in this, but this is the way applications are designed.
|
| 18. Posted By: Tom - - May 27, 2008, 11:22 pm |
Program/Method: Windows XP
Network Type: 802.11g wifi
Size of file: 616 MB
Transfer Time: 34 min
Transfer Speed: 2.42 mbps
Even using a mapped network drive, only get about 6% network utilization showing on task manager.
|
| 19. Posted By: Jeremy - - June 9, 2008, 7:09 pm |
Program/Method: Windows vista
Network Type: 802.11g
Size of file: 9124 MB
Transfer Time: 7 min
Transfer Speed: 173.79 mbps
|
| 20. Posted By: Rafael - - June 18, 2008, 12:29 pm |
Program/Method: Map Drive XP Pro SP2 x XP Pro SP2
Network Type: Board to board Cross-Over 100Mbps Ethernet
Size of file: 200 MB
Transfer Time: 0.12 min
Transfer Speed: 222.22 mbps
|
| 21. Posted By: kael - - June 18, 2008, 11:52 pm |
Program/Method: XP file sharing
Network Type: 802.11g (54mbps) wifi
Size of file: 3942 MB
Transfer Time: 80 min
Transfer Speed: 6.57 mbps
|
| 22. Posted By: Rankin - - July 4, 2008, 7:47 pm |
Program/Method: CrossFTP Server
Network Type: Ethernet 100 Mbps
Size of file: 1024 MB
Transfer Time: 114 seconds
Transfer Speed: 71.86 mbps
This was a transfer from an old Win2K Pro box (a single file on a Maxtor 80GB ATA-133 HDD) to a server running Fedora Core 7 and CrossFTP Server. The FC7 box is connected to a switch which connects to both a router and the DSL modem, and behind that router and another 2 switches is the Win2K box. All switches and routers are rated for 100 Mbps Ethernet (the router happens to be 802.11 Draft N rated, but that wasn't used). DSL modem (which wasn't used, since it was an intranet transfer) runs at 6 Mbps download 1-1.5 Mbps upload.
|
| 23. Posted By: HappyGuy - - September 24, 2008, 6:41 pm |
I just want to drop in to say thanks for this information. I never realize that copying files over mapped drives is faster than UNC paths. Would be able to do a follow up article which tests the copy methods, such as robocopy, wget, or any other utilites out there that the average user may not know about? Thanks and keep up the good work.
|
| 24. Posted By: user - - October 30, 2008, 8:22 pm |
The reason you saw no difference when using mode z is because you likely sent over a media or executable file. Mode z uses on the fly compression and can greatly the size of files containing largely text or otherwise easily compressible data. Media (music, movies, pictures, etc), executables, and compressed files do not fall under this category so you will see no gain (and maybe some loss due to the overhead of compressing the file).
|
| 25. Posted By: Rick - - December 7, 2008, 8:58 pm |
I'd be curious to see a 802.11n transfer. Wireless sure takes a toll!
|
| 26. Posted By: John - - January 15, 2009, 6:45 pm |
Network 45Mbps WAN link from Japan to North America
File size: 6144MB
Using regular FTP the transfer took 44 hours, with FileCatayst it only took 20 minutes. We fund out that on WAN links - FileCatalyst gave us really fast file trasfer. FileCatalyst uses UDP based protocol to speed up the file transfer.
|
| 27. Posted By: JoeG - - April 14, 2009, 12:48 pm |
Hey, awesome stuff. I'm glad someone took the time to actually do what you did here it saved me. i was trying to transfer 16 gb over my network and i did not want to use WiFi, i set up a mapped drive to my sever and it was over in just over 25 minutes. I've heard of the firewire networks I would have tried it however i dont have a cable. I am going to try it if you would be interested in the results i'll send them along.
Thanks,
Joe G
|
| 28. Posted By: Aitoh - - May 9, 2009, 5:40 am |
Program/Method: MSN Messenger
Network Type: Ethernet 100MBps
Size of file: 7290 MB
Transfer Time: 25 min
Transfer Speed: 38.88 mbps
|
| 29. Posted By: Khan - - May 13, 2009, 1:31 am |
Program/Method: Map a Drive Letter
Network Type: 802.11b wifi
Size of file: 702 MB
Transfer Time: 10 min
Transfer Speed: 9.36 mbps
|
| 30. Posted By: Jeff - - May 28, 2009, 10:17 pm |
Hi Joe. Thanks for the comment. I didn't see your message until recently. I would love to see your results for transferring over firewire. But I am really amazed that you transferred 16gb over wifi in 25 minutes! That is quite fast. What was the wifi type? Or did you connect the PCs with an ethernet cable?
|
| 31. Posted By: Jeff - - June 3, 2009, 12:02 am |
Program/Method: windows xp mapped drive letter
Network Type: 802.11g 54mbps wifi
Size of file: 1540 MB
Transfer Time: 12 min
Transfer Speed: 17.11 mbps
|
| 32. Posted By: Jeff - - June 9, 2009, 6:55 pm |
Program/Method: windows xp mapped drive letter
Network Type: 802.11g wifi
Size of file: 403 MB
Transfer Time: 3 min
Transfer Speed: 17.91 mbps
|
| 33. Posted By: Jeff - - September 1, 2009, 4:54 pm |
Program/Method: Internet Explorer
Network Type: 6.0 AT&T DSL
Size of file: 74 MB
Transfer Time: 2 min
Transfer Speed: 4.93 mbps
|
| 34. Posted By: dirtysoutho7 - - September 2, 2009, 5:36 am |
Program/Method: hamachi
Network Type: 802.11b/g/n 300mbps
Size of file: 3072 MB
Transfer Time: 15 min
Transfer Speed: 27.31 mbps
hamachi is crap it is good for games
i need to try something else any sugg
|
| 35. Posted By: Johann - - October 5, 2009, 5:54 am |
Program/Method: http
Network Type: DSL DSL 864/160 kBit/s
Size of file: 1.892 MB
Transfer Time: 0.43 min
Transfer Speed: 0.59 mbps
I downloaded a jpg from a Google server (presumably located in the US) from my location in Europe. Even with Google's high speed servers, it appears the using Http is still a slow way of transferring files in comparison to a mapped file.
|
| 36. Posted By: Bruce - - October 11, 2009, 10:07 am |
Just a note about mapped drives. I like them but there is at least one downfall if you use MS Office applications. When you browse to open documents, in some cases (usually if the PC with the drive is turned off) a mapped drive will cause the application to hang for a while. It's trying to resolve the mapped drive that is not available and I've had this take several minutes before it gives up and let's you browse for a file on your own pc. If you leave all your computers running, you should be OK.
|
| 37. Posted By: Jeff - - October 27, 2009, 12:28 pm |
Program/Method: windows mapped drive
Network Type: 802.11g wifi
Size of file: 1609 MB
Transfer Time: 14 min
Transfer Speed: 15.32 mbps
|
| 38. Posted By: art - - November 1, 2009, 8:01 am |
Program/Method: shares windows XP >> mac OSX
Network Type: 10 mbps ethernet
Size of file: 92000 MB
Transfer Time: 1980 min
Transfer Speed: 6.2 mbps
Bummer, and I thought my network was 100 mbps... Time to start troubleshooting!
|
| 39. Posted By: Brian - - December 18, 2009, 12:45 am |
When considering your transfer speeds do not forget that overhead, hard drive speeds(the big one for gigabit or even fast ethernet with slow drives), and sometimes various bus speeds can all play a part in slowing you down.
|
| 40. Posted By: Jeff - - January 28, 2010, 12:07 pm |
Program/Method: Windows Vista Shared Drive
Network Type: 802.11g wifi
Size of file: 501 MB
Transfer Time: 6 min
Transfer Speed: 11.13 mbps
|
| 41. Posted By: dimi - dimitrgr@hotmail.com - January 31, 2010, 1:37 pm |
Program/Method: windows xp mapped drive/ teracopy
Network Type: 802.11b wifi
Size of file: 122 MB
Transfer Time: 3 min
Transfer Speed: 5.42 mbps
|
| 42. Posted By: Jeff - - February 1, 2010, 12:11 pm |
Hey Dimi,
Thanks for the post and telling us that you used "Teracopy". It looks like you may have had some faster speed using it. However, I it may depend on the type of file you were transferring. It looks like I may have to add a "type of file" or "file extension" field to the list of questions.
Jeff
|
| 43. Posted By: splender99 - - March 2, 2010, 8:16 pm |
To make this accurate, all samples must use the same file to transfer. It will make the comparison a little valid.
|
| 44. Posted By: Jeff - - March 3, 2010, 1:20 pm |
Splender99, Thanks for the comment. When I transfer files it is generally AVI video files. So the files can't be compressed anymore by the file transfer protocol. So for my file transfer tests it pretty much accurately shows the correct transfer speed.
Jeff
www.seabreezecomputers.com
|
| 45. Posted By: ac - - March 7, 2010, 7:00 am |
Program/Method: ftp
Network Type: 802.11g
Size of file: 730 MB
Transfer Time: 21 min
Transfer Speed: 4.63 mbps
Program/Method: ftp
Network Type: 802.11g
Size of file: 1000 MBop
Transfer Time: 21 min
Transfer Speed: 6.35 mbps
Filetype is h.231 encoded video.
This was using ftp PUT from a Ubuntu 9.10 laptop (1.6GHz, 160GB PATA drive) over wireless to a very old and very slow Linksys NAS200 (2 1-T drives in RAID 1). The NAS200 is wired into the router; the laptop is wireless.
|
| 46. Posted By: Tom K - - March 14, 2010, 7:28 am |
Program/Method: Windows 7 mapped X Drive
Network Type: 802.11g wifi
Size of file: 7333 MB
Transfer Time: 27 min
Transfer Speed: 36.21 mbps
Windows 7 reported 2.19 MB/s file was .iso image file
|
| 47. Posted By: jim - - September 15, 2010, 8:47 am |
@Bruce: "When you browse to open documents, in some cases (usually if the PC with the drive is turned off) a mapped drive will cause the application to hang for a while."
This can be fixed going to folder options in explorer and turn off "automatically search for network folders & printers". speeds up explorer!
|
| 48. Posted By: Dave - - October 24, 2010, 10:17 pm |
Program/Method: xp copy with Teracopy shell to mapped drive
Network Type: 802.11g (54 Mbps)
Size of file: 33 MB (video)
Transfer Time: 0.55 min
Transfer Speed: 8 mbps
Tweaking the protocols for each wireless network connection's Properties to get a minimal set prevents conflicts and time-wasting. MS Network Monitor is a free packet sniffer.
|
| 49. Posted By: Whitebox - - October 29, 2010, 3:45 am |
Program/Method: Windows file sharing
Network Type: 30 metres Cat 5e from XP PC to USB HDD that is piggybacking on a WD Mybook Word Edition II NAS (Busybox linux)
Size of file: 16180 MB
Transfer Time: 70 min
Transfer Speed: 30.82 mbps
|
| 50. Posted By: Jeff - - November 10, 2010, 3:14 pm |
Program/Method: windows file sharing
Network Type: 802.11g 54mbps
Size of file: 16000 MB
Transfer Time: 100 min
Transfer Speed: 21.33 mbps
|